Book Review: The Forgetting Moon
By Elizabeth Suggs
The Forgetting Moon by Brian Lee Durfee swept me into a world I thought I knew, only to turn those expectations upside down in the best way possible.
Right from the start, I was hooked by the intricate world-building. The Five Isles are steeped in complex religious systems and political intrigue that makes every chapter feel like a fresh discovery. The depth Brian put into creating this world—especially the theology—was impressive and refreshing. You can tell he’s not just writing another cookie-cutter fantasy, but one that takes time to develop each culture, race, and belief system into something truly immersive.
The characters, too, are far from typical. You’ve got Gault, an elite knight who starts questioning everything about the crusade he’s leading, and then there’s Jondralyn, desperate to prove herself as a warrior in a kingdom that only values her beauty. And let's not forget Tala, her younger sister, digging into secrets that could unravel everything. Oh, and Hawkwood? The assassin sent to kill Jondralyn who falls in love with her instead? Yeah, I’m here for all that tension.
One of the things I appreciated most is how The Forgetting Moon blends grimdark elements with character growth. Brian doesn’t shy away from the brutal realities of war, loss, and betrayal, but the characters’ personal struggles to hold on to their faith, family, and identities give the story an emotional backbone.
At over 800 pages, it’s a massive read, but the pacing never felt slow. Every chapter has intention. Every twist feels earned. Brian teases us with mysteries—reminding us repeatedly that we shouldn’t trust anyone—and it’s so much fun trying to piece it all together.
This book is full of intrigue, conspiracies, and questions about identity that get under your skin. And knowing that Brian still has more to reveal? It makes me even more excited for the rest of the series. If you’re looking for a dark, character-driven epic fantasy that’s anything but predictable, grab The Forgetting Moon. It’s a ride, and I’m so glad Brian handed me this gem personally.
Quotes I loved:
“Without food, we’ll be reduced to stumbling skeletons in days.”
“These twining branches of water cascaded over the steep path like skeletal white fingers.”
“I owe every victory to you. You were my inspiration.”